top of page
Search

Holding Both Truths: The Internal And the External of Emotional Well-Being

Fallon Coster
10 minutes ago
7 min read

out of my control, anxiety, hopeless

Understanding the relationship between our external circumstances, internal experiences, and opportunities for meaningful change.


One of the most meaningful aspects of therapy is learning to hold multiple truths at the same time. We can acknowledge that life presents genuine challenges while also recognizing opportunities for growth, change, and meaningful progress. We can validate the impact of our external circumstances while exploring the internal beliefs, thought patterns, and emotional responses that influence how we navigate those circumstances.


This concept is rooted in dialectical thinking, which encourages us to move away from all-or-nothing perspectives and make room for multiple experiences and realities. In therapy, this approach can be especially meaningful when exploring the relationship between social factors in health, anxiety, emotional well-being, and our ability to function in everyday life.


Understanding the Impact of Our External Circumstances

Our mental health does not exist independently of the world around us. The environments we live in, resources available to us, relationships, financial circumstances, cultural experiences, and access to healthcare all contribute to our emotional well-being.


Social factors of health refer to the social, economic, and environmental conditions that influence health and quality of life. These include economic stability, housing, education, healthcare access, neighborhood environments, and social and community support.


Consider how difficult it can be to prioritize mental health when experiencing financial insecurity, navigating discrimination, managing care-giving responsibilities, or struggling to access necessary resources. These circumstances can create ongoing stressors that affect our nervous systems, relationships, self-esteem, and ability to feel secure.


It is important to recognize that these experiences cannot always be resolved through a change in perspective or an adjustment in thinking. Sometimes the stressor is external, systemic, and outside of an individual's immediate control.


Acknowledging these realities is an important part of compassionate mental healthcare. These circumstances deserve to be understood, validated, and considered when exploring our mental health.


Understanding Our Internal Experiences: How Thought Systems Influence Well-Being

While external circumstances significantly influence mental health, we also have an internal experience that deserves attention.


Our beliefs, interpretations, expectations, and thought patterns influence how we understand ourselves and respond to the world around us. When experiencing ongoing stress, our minds may develop ways of interpreting situations that reinforce anxiety, hopelessness, self-criticism, or feelings of inadequacy.


Someone experiencing financial instability or difficulty meeting personal goals may begin to internalize beliefs such as:

  • I should be further along in life by now.

  • I am failing because I cannot manage everything.

  • Things will never get better.

  • I cannot feel secure until every problem is resolved.

  • I should be able to handle this without needing help.

Although these thoughts may develop in response to genuine challenges, they can also create additional emotional distress.


Therapy provides an opportunity to explore where these belief systems originated, how they influence daily functioning, and whether they accurately reflect our experiences, values, and abilities.


This is not about dismissing the circumstances that contribute to distress. Rather, it is about recognizing the difference between what is happening around us and the additional meanings, expectations, and judgments we may be placing on ourselves.


We can begin to challenge the belief that experiencing difficulty means we are inadequate. We can explore the possibility that needing support does not mean we are incapable. We can acknowledge uncertainty without automatically assuming that the future will remain the same.


These shifts can create room for self-compassion, emotional flexibility, and a greater sense of agency.


Learning to Hold Multiple Truths

Dialectics in therapy invite us to move beyond the idea that seemingly opposing experiences cannot coexist.

  • Life can be genuinely difficult, and I can still identify moments of joy.

  • My circumstances may be outside of my control, and I can identify areas where I have choices.

  • I can feel overwhelmed by my responsibilities, and I can work toward building healthier boundaries.

  • I can acknowledge the impact of systemic barriers, and I can advocate for the resources and opportunities I deserve.

  • I can validate my anxiety, and I can challenge the thoughts that intensify it.

  • I can recognize how much I have struggled, and I can remain optimistic about what may be possible.

  • I can accept where I am today, and I can continue working toward where I want to be.


This both/and thought system approach is particularly important when people feel pressure to choose between acknowledging their struggles and maintaining a positive outlook.


Sometimes we may worry that recognizing hope means minimizing the challenges, that acknowledging our struggles means giving up on the possibility of change.

Neither has to be the only pathway.


We can make space for the complexity of our experiences without requiring ourselves to resolve every contradiction. This creates an opportunity to develop a more balanced relationship with ourselves, our circumstances, and our expectations.


How Therapy Can Help Challenge Unhelpful Thought Systems

Therapy offers a supportive environment to explore the relationship between external circumstances and internal experiences. Rather than focusing exclusively on symptom reduction, the therapeutic process can help individuals better understand the broader context of their mental health.


Some areas of exploration may include:

Identifying internalized expectations and belief systems

We can explore the expectations we place on ourselves and consider how they have been influenced by family systems, cultural messages, societal pressures, and personal experiences. This may include examining beliefs about productivity, success, relationships, independence, or what it means to be doing well in life.


Developing awareness of anxiety patterns

Anxiety can influence how we interpret uncertainty, anticipate future experiences, and assess our ability to manage challenges. Therapy can help identify patterns such as catastrophizing, all-or-nothing thinking, overgeneralization, and excessive responsibility.

Recognizing these patterns allows us to consider alternative perspectives without invalidating the circumstances that contributed to our anxiety.


Building self-compassion and validation

We can work toward recognizing that our emotional responses often make sense within the context of our experiences. Instead of judging ourselves for struggling, we can develop curiosity about what our emotions are communicating and what needs may be going unmet.


Identifying areas of agency and control

Not everything is within our control, but there may be meaningful areas where we can make decisions, establish boundaries, seek support, or take action. Therapy can help distinguish between what requires acceptance, what may benefit from problem-solving, and what may require external advocacy or additional resources.


Developing realistic and meaningful goals

Rather than creating goals based on external expectations or unrealistic standards, therapy can help individuals identify what improvement actually looks like for them. This may involve building routines, strengthening relationships, prioritizing rest, increasing self-advocacy, or making incremental changes that support emotional well-being.


Moving Toward Optimism Without Minimizing Reality

Optimism in therapy does not mean believing everything will work out perfectly. It does not require ignoring difficult circumstances, overlooking injustice, or maintaining a positive attitude when things are painful.


Instead, optimism can be understood as developing the ability to recognize that our current circumstances do not necessarily define every future possibility.


It is the ability to acknowledge that something is difficult without concluding that it is impossible to navigate. It is recognizing that we may not have control over every outcome while still identifying opportunities to participate in our own well-being.


Sometimes optimism looks like making a significant life change. Other times, it looks like asking for help, allowing ourselves to rest, challenging an unhelpful belief, or recognizing that we have made progress even when our external circumstances have not changed.


Therapy can help us identify these moments and build a more compassionate understanding of what progress means. This work does not place the responsibility for overcoming systemic barriers on the individual. Personal growth and emotional well-being are supported by access to resources, equitable opportunities, meaningful relationships, and environments that allow people to thrive. We deserve both individual support and broader social conditions that make well-being possible.


Honoring the Complexity of Being Human

One of the things I value about the therapeutic process is the opportunity to make room for complexity. We do not have to reduce our experiences to good or bad, successful or unsuccessful, hopeful or hopeless.


We can acknowledge that the world presents genuine challenges while also recognizing that our internal experiences deserve care and attention. We can validate the ways our circumstances have affected us while exploring how we might develop new perspectives, strengthen our coping strategies, and move toward goals that feel meaningful.


The goal is not to convince ourselves that things are easier than they are. It is to develop the ability to recognize our experiences more fully, including both the challenges we face and the possibilities that remain available to us.


Sometimes meaningful change begins with allowing two things to be true: I can acknowledge how difficult things are right now, and I can believe that there are still opportunities for growth, connection, and a greater sense of well-being.


That is the value of dialectical thinking in therapy. It allows us to honor our reality without limiting our future, validate our struggles without defining ourselves by them, and build a relationship with ourselves that makes room for both acceptance and change.


Reflection Questions: Practicing the Both/And Approach

Consider using these questions as journaling prompts or opportunities for further exploration in therapy:

  1. What external circumstances are currently contributing to my stress or anxiety? How can I acknowledge their impact without blaming myself for experiencing difficulty?

  2. What expectations am I placing on myself that may be influenced by societal pressures rather than my personal values and needs?

  3. Where might my thought patterns be adding another layer of distress to an already challenging situation?

  4. What are two truths I am having difficulty holding simultaneously about my current circumstances?

  5. What aspects of my well-being can I begin to prioritize, even if I cannot immediately change my external circumstances?

  6. What would optimism look like if it did not require me to minimize, dismiss, or invalidate what I am experiencing?

Therapy can be a space to explore these questions with curiosity, compassion, and an understanding that meaningful progress does not require us to dismiss the realities of our lives.


 
 
Open Path Therapy Collective for affordable mental health care through telehealth.

© 2026 by Fallon Coster, LCSW

bottom of page